Information and Links

Join the fray by commenting, tracking what others have to say, or linking to it from your blog.

Other Posts
The Blessed Mawlid by Imam Zaid Shakir
Can Citizens Take Law Into Their Own Hands When the Authorities Don’t Do Their Job?

Imam Ghazali on Presence of Heart in Prayer

Posted by Hamza Karamali, SunniPath Instructor on March 30th, 2007

In the Name of Allah, Most Merciful and Compassionate

Last week, in my Essentials of Islam class, we covered the inner dimensions of prayer from Muhtar Holland’s excellent book, The Inner Dimensions of Islamic Worship. I prepared for my weekly live session with the students by reading what Imam Ghazali had to say about presence of heart in prayer in his famous work, Ihya’ `Ulum al-Din. While preparing, I stumbled across the following thought-provoking passage:

… Powerful, overburdening desires, however, cannot be soothed into silence. Instead, they will engage you in a tug-of-war that they will eventually win, and you will be busied throughout your prayer in the contest.

This state of affairs can be compared to a man under a tree who wants to concentrate his thoughts on a particular matter, but the chirping of sparrows keeps distracting him. He shoos them away with a stick and returns to his thoughts, but the sparrows keep coming back, and he keeps having to get up and shoo them away.

It would be said to this man, “This is like the movement of watering-camels: it will never come to an end. If you want to put an end to the matter, then chop down the tree.”

Such is the tree of desires [in the heart of the worshipper]: whenever its branches spread out, distracting thoughts are attracted to it just like sparrows are attracted to trees, and just like flies are attracted to garbage …

There are many such desires, and few a worshipper is entirely free of them. They all spring from a single root, namely, the love of this world, which is the source of every misdeed, the foundation of every loss, and the wellspring of every corruption. Whoever finds that his heart contains love of this world, such that it inclines to any worldly matter, not to use it as a provision or as an aid to the next life [but as a goal in itself], then he should never hope that the delight of intimate conversation with the divine should open up for him in prayer … (Ihya `Ulum al-Din, 4 vols, Beirut: Dar Sader, 2000, 1.223-24)

Besides being a beautiful and insightful account of why many of us are unable to focus in prayer, this passage also teaches us a number of seemingly unrelated lessons, one on how to measure one’s sincerity, and another on the importance of treading the spiritual path. More on that in future posts, Allah willing.



Write a Comment

Take a moment to comment and tell us what you think. Some basic HTML is allowed for formatting.

Please note that teachers will reply to questions about their post for only a couple of days after the original post. But any comments are always welcome.

Reader Comments

But doesn’t that seem pretty hard? It would seem then that the vast majority of Muslims “should never hope that the delight of intimate conversation with the divine should open up for him in prayer” - what are some practical advices in which we can fulfill what the great Hujjat al-Islam is saying.

Very good insight into the problem.

What is very funny/irritating is that when is doing the prayer - the thoughts that come to you appear to completely dissappear when the prayer ends and you go about your day to day duties.

One thing for me that helps is to understand the meaning of what you are saying in the prayer. As Arabic is not my first language - i have to translate it into english in my mind as i am saying it and this sometimes helps.

Funnily enough i find it much easier to do my prayer after just finishing one of these lessons on the courses.

[This is a response to Sidi Omar’s comment]

The way to read what Imam Ghazali is saying is, “Wow! I want to be like that!” not, “That’s impossible!” Imam Ghazali is trying to get us to embark on a process of self-purification, not to get us to lose hope in the divine generosity.

You’re right, though: it is difficult. But so is getting a medical degree, and so is learning how to swim, for example. Everything worth having requires work, and this is no exception. The key point to keep in mind is that although it is difficult, it is not impossible.

I will, Allah willing, write a follow-up post on this very topic. Stay tuned. :)

[…] SunniPath Blog - » Imam Ghazali on Presence of Heart in Prayer …what Imam Ghazali had to say about presence of heart in prayer in his famous work, Ihya’ `Ulum al-Din. While preparing, I stumbled across the following thought-provoking passage […]

[…] Imam Ghazali’s diagnosis of the problem of heedlessness during prayer has an interesting consequence: anything that distracts us from Allah Most High during our prayer is, in reality, dunya, even if it outwardly appears to be religious. This is a powerful tool that we can use to measure our sincerity in the projects that we undertake. […]

The key to our sincerity in prayer is linked to our preparation for the prayer. Time is of the essence. So is apearance (Niyyah - Surah Maa oon) We must approach prayer with dignity. (as if we see Allah in front of us - hadith) A contributing bad habit is to leave our prayers for the last moments and be rushed and similarly to be unconcerned with the actual performance of wudu - the key to salaah. I recommend some tahajjud.

Masha-Allah, it was worth a read. And as for distractions, we all get distracted and understandably so, living in the present world has made it a struggle for Muslims to keep up with their imaan to the highest, and retain the purification in their hearts and souls and in their worships. I find that even when im able to get rid of certain distractions and able to focus on my spirituality, the distractions do keep coming back like those crows. And that factor sometimes causes a lot of frustration. We seek refuge in Allah — for the love of dunya is not going to lead us anywhere but destruction. Sidi, could you please eloborate on how must one persist in freeing oneself from the distractions of this dunya and stay focused on their ultimate goal?
Barak Allah feek, Wassalamu alaykum

Bismillah
as sallamu alaikum

Inshaa Allah maybe someone could post some of the means one can take in order to attain this Presence of Heart in Prayer. That Imam Ghazali (Rahmatullah) is speaking about.

[…] 17 Apr 2007 Presence of Heart in Prayer Posted by seekerofsacredilm under Uncategorized  Imam Ghazali on Presence of Heart inPrayer […]

Here’s a link on how to increase presence of heart in prayer by Sheikh Amjad (May Allah preserve him)

http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=3&ID=3631&CATE=431

Bismillah ir-Rahman ir-Rahim

One is coming of a stray thought by it self, another is to bring a thought in one’s mind. The latter is obviously not allowed.

For the thoughts which enter by them selves, what I learned from the teachings of my shaykh about presence of the heart is that, as soon as you realize that you are thinking about something worldly in the prayer, try to change your thought. Do as much as what is in your control… and worry not about what’s not in your control. Every time you realize that you’re entertaining on a stray thought in your prayer, try changing your thought… by thinking of Allah Ta’ala. Now, as soon as you tried focusing your attention towards Allah Ta’ala, while you were in the process of that, another stray thought came into your heart and mind… whithout you realizing it… and it took you away for a good while. Now, as soon as you realize again that you’re thinking of something you shouldn’t be thinking about… try to do the same. Even if the thought of Zina comes in your mind, as soon as you realize, immediately change your thought. InshaAllah Ta’ala by trying sincerely our best, Allah Ta’ala would give His presence in our hearts.

[…] SunniPath Blog - » Presence of Heart in Prayer as a Measure of Sincerity - Shaykh Hamza Karamali Imam Ghazali’s diagnosis of the problem of heedlessness during prayer has an interesting consequence: anything that distracts us from Allah Most High during our prayer is, in reality, dunya,even if it outwardly appears to be religious. […]

A friend once said something interesting: “I don’t bother controlling my thoughts in prayer, I just ignore them and try to see past them, sort of like how you ignore the background noises when listening to somebody speak or when looking at the sun through the clouds - just ignore the unimportant stuff.”

@student:
You make it sound so easy!

They only time where someone can lose all thoughts is when they are risking their lives, like bungy-jumping or something.. It takes practice to get to that stage of not thinking about anything without risking ur life - as in prayer.

and when you look at the sun, do enjoy its clouds. ;)

In order to attain absolute sincerity in prayer, one must purify his heart from worldliness as Imam Ghazali said… And it can only be done through mastering the science of Tasawwuf…